6/30/2023 0 Comments Makin atoll![]() But the venture was short-lived by his own admission he was a terrible lawyer and lost the few cases he handled. Despite a privileged upbringing in Alabama, he eschewed the trappings of rank, preferring to wear a combat uniform rather than dress whites.Īs had been expected of him, Holland followed his father, a prominent lawyer, into law, joining his firm immediately after law school. ![]() Lieutenant General Holland McTyeire Smith prided himself on his ability to relate to the common Marine. T he two men at the center of the controversy were a study in contrasts. Instead, Smith’s relief became the opening salvo of a battle that raged through the remainder of the war and beyond. After all, three other Army division commanders had been relieved in the Pacific Theater-two of them by naval commanders-without threatening service relations. Nonetheless, all involved assumed that Ralph Smith’s relief from duty would be accepted as little more than a routine wartime shuffling of commanders. As for the Marines, there was a perpetual-and well-founded-fear that the Army was scheming to absorb the Corps into its own structure. Many Army officers, for example, still resented the Marines for receiving what seemed like an outsized share of praise after the 1918 Battle of Belleau Wood. The tensions that erupted at Saipan didn’t originate there, but resulted from the opening of wounds the two services had barely patched over since World War I. Almost from the beginning of their acquaintance, Holland Smith, a jowly bulldog of a man in his early 60s, was openly contemptuous of the abilities of the Army in general-and of the 27th Division and Ralph Smith in particular. He left Saipan without being allowed to say goodbye to the officers and men he had led for over 18 months through three bloody battles.ĭuring that time, Ralph Smith had had a strained relationship with the Marine V Corps’ commander, Lieutenant General Holland Smith. Smith and Jarman continued their conversation well into the night, breaking off only when a second message arrived ordering Smith to pack his personal belongings and be on a Hawaii-bound plane before daybreak. He then called his officers together and told them what he’d known since receiving the message earlier that afternoon: he had been relieved of command, and Jarman was taking over. Smith gave Jarman a detailed briefing of the current situation and went over his plans for the flanking attacks in minute detail. He visited his forward positions and returned to his division headquarters to find Major General Sanderford Jarman waiting for him. To get his division moving again, Smith planned to halt the frontal attacks and start launching aggressive flanking actions the next morning. The delay was holding up the larger corps attack, a fact that had been pointed out to Smith-a tall, quiet man of 50 with the demeanor of the academic he later became-in a terse telegram from the corps commander earlier that day. For several days, two of his regiments had conducted fruitless frontal assaults on Japanese positions along areas the soldiers had christened Purple Heart Ridge and Death Valley, with little to show for their efforts besides casualties. ![]() Smith read the message, pocketed it without comment, and returned to the task at hand-the battle raging just outside his tent. On the afternoon of June 24, 1944, a messenger from the Marines’ V Amphibious Corps headquarters entered the frontline command post of the Army’s 27th Infantry Division on Saipan and handed a message to Major General Ralph C. 'Howlin' Mad' WWII Marine General Goes to War with Army Close ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |